Showing posts with label broadway. Show all posts
Showing posts with label broadway. Show all posts

Ragtime: A Review

I didn't have the pleasure of seeing Ragtime the first time that it was on Broadway 10 years ago. I've read the reviews though, essentially everyone agrees that it was a great show, had enormous potential, but that the production was a bit lacking, and would be too big for very many theaters off Broadway to ever produce. It is sort of a white whale of a show requiring a cast of around 40, a car, several widely varied locations, a ton of period costuming... it really is a difficult show to put on with any sort of a small budget. Thankfully the Kennedy Center produced a new large scale production that was so well received that it was brought to Broadway again, a bare decade since it originally closed, which is pretty unusual. But I agree, this show is well worth it, and more than ready to come back.

The show itself is an odd animal, and sort of weirdly presentational. No one outside of the historic characters (like Booker T Washington and Harry Houdini) has a name, and instead refer to each other as "Mother" or "Father." The most off putting being "Younger Brother." It is just an awkward mouthful, especially when the character refers to himself in third person that way. Once you get past this quirk though the show is packed with drama and story. Three families interweave through a single year in their lives, 1906, and any one of the families' stories would be more than enough to pack most shows, but the deft weaving of these threes stories is where the real power of this show lies.

There are some powerful performances here. Christiane Noll as "Mother" is by far the strongest performance in the show. Her character arc cuts to the heart of everything that was happening in this era, changing attitudes on race, and on the woman's place in society, the changing role of the mother, the new attitudes about child rearing and family... it is a lot to carry, and she does it perfectly. Every line, even the third person expository toss offs, are wrung fully dry of their meaning, and it is at turns hilarious and heart breaking.

The other outstanding performance is Quentin Earl Darrington as Coalhouse Walker. Here is another role burdened by layer after layer of story, a ragtime piano player with an illegitimate child who is struggling to be the perfect example of his race as Booker T Washington has taught him, but at the same time being crushed under institutional racism. Coalhouse has some power-packed songs that will leave you breathless, and handles two of the shows biggest props, the car and the piano, with grace.

The set is a wonder, a three story cast-iron style catwalk that with ease becomes a ship, a factory, a home, a theatre, a library... a dozen things. The set is minimal in some ways but full of Victorian styling if you know where to look. It echos the cast-iron buildings of Soho and middle Manhattan, as well as place like the Crystal Pavilion and the the original Penn Station that were so important to the aesthetics of this era. The larger props follow this idea, being little more than frameworks that suggest the prop, but keep them in the light and airy style of the set. (You can sort of make out the piano in the background of this shot.) It is an incredibly versatile way of creating the set that supports the show, but leaves most of the visual cueing to the costumes, which are also beautiful, and easily capable of supporting the show. The color coding at the top of the show (the white cast in creams and tans, the black cast in rusts and yellows, the immigrants in grays and blacks) is incredibly effective, and that sort of thought carries through the show, leaving the big "pops" of color to the entertainers (Evelyn Nesbitt and Harry Houdini) or the bands that march through on occasion. My only wish is that the set designer had trusted his concept and run with it for the whole show. Tateh's cart, the library furniture and the funeral wagon, are all far too real and solid, and step away from the way everything else is presented in a distracting way. The worst example is the street light that is dragged in for Coalhouse's dream in Act 2. It doesn't turn on (that may have been an error, this is still in previews) doesn't match the style of the set, and adds very little to the sequence. Cut it and trust the set to do its job, it is succeeding wildly on most other occasions. My other tiny quibble with the set is the central catwalk, that raises and lowers at several points in the show. They seriously need to check the rigging on that thing. There is a point in the second act where about 8 people are standing on it and with each new person that stepped on it dropped several inches. It took me right out of the show because I was afraid for the actors! I have no idea if anyone besides me would ever notice such a thing though.

I would be remiss if I didn't mention the fact that this production also boasts a 28 piece orchestra. Most Broadway productions these days make do with 15 pieces, if that, and I really never knew what an experience I was missing. The full rich sound that this orchestra produces is far superior, and will make you long to hear other shows produced this way.

In all, a nearly 5 star show. I am very happy to have seen it and would recommend it to anyone who is coming through the city.

Coraline: A Review

Well, that was... interesting.

Coraline, recently a stop motion animation movie, but originally a book by Neil Gaiman has now also been adapted into a musical by Stephin Merritt of the band Magnetic Fields. The original book, as with most things Gaiman, is a quirky little piece about growing up and discovering who you really are, and monsters. The musical is made even quirkier by the fact that it is, for the most part, orchestrated on an entirely unorthodox collection of objects, ballons, styrofoam coolers, chopsticks, and toy pianos among them. The vast majority of the show is played on toy piano, and when a real piano is utilized it is in unconventional ways like plucking the strings, or brushing them with forms and steel brushes. The ensemble cast plays dozens of characters each, ranging from rats and mice to the human inhabitants of Coraline's world.

The story is epic, a young girl exploring two different worlds and meeting dozens of denizens of both, and the challenge is to move seamlessly between the locations and times. The set consists primarily of various deconstructed pianos scattered about or built into assemblages, and several doors. Doors play a big part in the story metaphorically, though the doors onstage are used only rarely. So the set itself doesn't really do much to add to the locale of the piece, most of that is accomplished by lighting shifts and the very clunky method of description. Nearly every scene is begun by Coraline announcing: "I am outside now." or "It's night now." Not exactly the most ideal way to carry a show.

Coraline herself is played by a much older woman which takes some mental acrobatics, at least for the first few minutes of the show. Some of the rest of the cast shine: Francis Jue for instance, especially when he is playing Miss Forcible the kindly spinster actress who lives next door. He and January LaVoy do a marvelous job as the actresses, and their scenes are some of the warmest and funniest in the show.

The show unfortunately never really reaches a destination. It lacks much in the way of suspense, which you need in a tale about a little girl fighting a demon, and all the songs seem interchangeable and sort of like outlines rather than actual songs. The rhymes comes off as forced and clunky, and vocals never really live up to the drama of the music being plunked out around the stage.

A good night of theatre, and I am happy to have seen it, but just not ready for the stage yet I'm afraid.

9 to 5 The Musical: A Review

You won't find a more devoted Dolly fan than me, and that's the hard truth. So I really went into this show wanting to like it. Allison Janney was of course another plus, as I love her as well, so my good will for this production was pretty high, which frankly was probably what allowed me to have such a good time with it.

The movie into musical phenomenon of the past few years has not exactly thrilled me. Most of the ones I've seen have left me pretty cold, and sadly this one didn't really fare much better. Movies just have a different pacing structure, and unless it is something where you can totally ditch the performances of the original actors, and bring something different to the table, then you are stuck with the comparisons. Of the three leads in this show I think Allison Janney went the furthest towards making Violet her own. She was able to overcome Lily Tomlin's portrayal, and made it fresh. Stephenie Block in Jane Fonda's role probably had the least to overcome, at least for me. But poor Megan Hilty was left with the real conundrum... to play Dora Lee, or to play Dolly Parton playing Dora Lee. Sadly they directed her towards the latter and I think that was to her doom. She lacks the personality to bring it off, and I can't help but wonder if the show would have been better off if they could have divorced Dora from Dolly and allowed an actress to create a new spin on the role. In the end all that is really required is for her to be a bit of a sex-bomb. There is nothing really Dolly specific in the role.

Dolly herself did an admirable job with the show. She wrote 16 new songs, and dusted off "9 to 5" and "Backwoods Barbie," extending them both and adding several new verses and reprise to "9 to 5." While the songs were solid, it was really apparent that she has never written for this genre before. The songs were almost entirely written as asides, and never integrated into the show as a way to progress the story the way they do in the best musicals. But still, fun music, and certainly it showed her trademark charm.

The set was... a bit overwhelming. Scott Pask turns in another admirable performance, but something just seemed... off. There certainly was a LOT of set. At times it seemed to be a show about set changes. There awlays seemed to be something in motion, some wall coming or going, or a line of desks shifting by. The best thing I saw was the movement between the outer office, where the secerataries sit to Mr. Hart's office, the scenery sort of inverted and folded in on itself to create the new space. A cool transition, at least the first time I saw it. The fourth... The rest of the show though just seemed clunky. The giant LED screen at the back was never really used to its full potential, and in fact was more often a distraction. Sadly the most clever thing on stage scenery wise was the act curtain, made of telephone hand sets and curled telephone cord.

In all... not a perfect show, perhaps not even a good show, but a FUN show. I had a good time, and in the end that's enough.

West Side Story: A Review

An enormous thank you to my friend Ruth who took me tonight to see the new revival of West Side Story. After a string of disappointing shows on Broadway it was great to finally see a show that made me happy (mostly.)

This is an absolutely GORGEOUS production. Jim Youmans left a lot to be desired in his set for Gypsy, his other collaboration with Arthur Laurents, but this set was a pure home run. The angles the color (or lack thereof) the texture... a beautiful collection scenes. The story of this show is based in the gang wars around 66th street on New York's West Side, in the tenements that were demolished to build Lincoln Center. Youmans seems to have shifted the action uptown a bit, specifically to the area of 125th St. underneath the 1 train. He directly lifted aspects of the set from that train bridge, combined with the softly textured and barely there backdrop of the George Washington Bridge. He also manages to pull off something that is incredibly difficult for a designer: making a scene shift meaningful. The shift into the set for the rumble "under the highway" was breathtaking and ominous and perfectly weighted. The huge diagonal shaft of the underside of the bridge coming in, appearing to drift in from a fog, and the lowering of the chain-link fence curtain perefectly set the mood for what was about to transpire onstage.

The costumes left aside the standard red and blue signifiers for the two gangs and instead went with orange and purple. There were touches of sage green and tans in everything, in all a very pleasing pallette. Tony and Maria were dressed in a deep teal blue, the only real blue onstage anywhere, though Tony does don an orange jacket for the fateful rumble. Using the secondary pallette rather than primaries was inspired.

The most beautiful thing on stage was "Somewhere." The cast in bleached out barely pastel shades of their gang colors, Tony and Maria in brilliant white, the stage basically bare against a stark, brightly lit cyc, and the song sung by a child in pure clean tones. That song alone is worth the price of admission.

Some words about the cast: Cody Green as Riff was a dream. Cody was the winner of Bravo's "Step It Up And Dance" and this show proves why. He looks like a short, squat brute, but he has the amazing ability to somehow magically lengthen his legs when he kicks, and creates these shapes that are stunning. It was a sad moment to realize that Riff's death meant that I wouldn't get to see him in the second act. The other stand out for me was Ryan Steele as Baby John. He somehow carries a tension in his dance that ripples out to the tips of his fingers and toes in every movement. He even snaps his fingers (which is important in this show as anyone who has seen it knows) in a way that moves his entire hand in a miniature dance. The vocal star of the show is Karen Olivo as Anita, a voice like a ringing bell that can carries humor, or emotion, and her rage after the rape scene is visceral. By far the strongest voice onstage in any scene.

I do have one complaint: the Spanish. Laurents chose to make about 50% of the Puerto Ricans' dialogue in Spanish, and chose to do "I Feel Pretty" and "A Boy Like That" entirely in Spanish. While I understand the choice... these are immigrants after all, and they probably would speak in a mix of English and Spanish (most of the people in my neighborhood do...) but it leaves the non-Spanish speaking audience a bit cheated. If you are unfamiliar with the show (and it hasn't been on Broadway in near 30 years) a big chunk of story is missing. How does Maria convince Anita that her love for Tony outweighs his having killed Anita's fiance? I don't know. It was in Spanish. Even "I Wanna Be In America" falls a bit flat because the pro-Puerto Rico arguments are made in Spanish, so the counter points and patter and puns make no sense. Yes, intellectually I get that he is alienating the audience as the immigrants are alientaed by their surroundings, and blah blah blah... I want to hear the story in a way that I can understand it. At least toss me the bone of some supertitles.

All in all, the best show I've seen in a while. Recomended.

Desire Under The Elms: A Review

Thanks to the vagaries of tickets being passed down through friends I got the opportunity tonight to see the current Broadway revival of Eugene O'Neill's "Desire Under The Elms."

Going into this show I knew nothing about it, other than it had a stellar cast, and had transferred from the the Goodman in Chicago. I checked a synopsis of the play... a pastoral drama, set in 1900's New England about three sons fighting to inherit their mean spirited and manipulative father's farm. It conjures certain images, right?

As the curtain rose I was greeted with something I NEVER expected. The show began with a burst of white light and the sound of an explosion as played on a bass. The set revealed behind the curtain was an enormous pile of grey stone with a dead pig hanging from its rear feet stage left. Large boulders were suspended from the fly by gigantic loops of rope and two men in filthy rags were moving stones around on stage. Is this a post-apocalyptic retelling of the story? Was I in the wrong theatre? I wasn't sure. A few minutes into the show as the three brothers had been introduced and the nugget of the conflict between them had started to be revealed I was faced with something even odder.

The basic thrust is this: Dad is an ass. The youngest son is only a half-brother to the other two, and the two older brothers know that they have no chance of inheriting the farm, so they are leaving. The younger son blames dad for working his mom to death and for stealing the land from her, so he assumes the land should rightfully be his when Dad kicks it. Dad has other ideas as he soon drags home a new bride who is under the assumption that all this will be HERS when her elderly husband shuffles off. So the over arcing theme of the show, the disposition of this farm, comes to be represented very literally by a two story farm house that is lowered in and spends the rest of the show suspended and dangling over the heads of the cast. Their greatest desire, just out of their reach, but ever present and threatening to crush them. Get it?

The weird boulders also continually hang there... but I never quite figured out what they were supposed to represent.

We are told repeatedly by the characters, both in dialogue and in wistful scenes where they stare off into the fourth wall, how "purdy" the land that they are fighting over is. All we can see as the audience is the grey of the rock, the house, the rear wall, the floor, the furniture... the never ending dull dreary grey. It really left me wondering why the heck anybody would be fighting over it in the first place. The youngest son even bribes his older brothers to leave, giving them enough money to sail to California and join the gold rush. Enough money in fact that he probably could have just bought his own land elsewhere and washed his hands of the entire problem. I THINK that his desire for the land was supposed to be truly about his desire to see his dead mother happy, but again, if the land were her spirit shouldn't it have been marginally comforting?

The show is rarely performed, and I can see why. It is written in a thick Maine (I guess?) dialect and is often hard to understand. None of the characters are particularly likable, and none of them seem like the type you want to root for. The script is often as bleak as the setting we were given. Granted O'Neill writes some dark, disturbed characters, but I can't help but wonder if we had seen some beautiful elms on stage, or a touch of any color at all in fact, would it have served as a better counter-point to the dreary script, rather than constantly underlining the script visually. I'm also not sure if it was just a function of the dating of the script, but there was never really a plot twist that I didn't see coming. Maybe in the intervening years too many people have ripped off these ideas, but every solution the characters had was at once obvious, and utterly wrong. Even their final decision, leaving the father alone and shattered, the sole possessor of the land he had tempted them with, seemed forced, and only to be made because the script demanded that they leave stage at that point.

I've seen in other reviews that a good deal of the dialogue was cut to keep the show at it's rather brisk 100 minutes (no intermission) which would explain why everything seemed very clipped and precise, with none of the expounding and expanding that O'Neill usually gives us. The situation never really seemed real, the stacatto delivery of every line in the show left me me with a feeling that I was watching a very good table read, but something that should flesh out more during rehearsal.

In all I would say that I would have found this an excellent production if it had been a bunch of graduate students. I think the director wanted a grand sweeping epic along the lines of Shakespeare (he also directed last year's Lear, with some of the same cast and creative team) but what he ended up with a post-apocalyptic Lifetime movie. At least the set was fun to look at, and intriguing to watch, even if the metaphor was a bit ham-fisted.

Gay Geek OVERLOAD

9 to 5 musical, book by the original author of the movie...

Completely new songs by Dolly...

Allison Janney as Violet...

ACK!!! It doesn't open until April!!! (Go watch here.)

Cry-Baby: A Review

Thanks to the generosity of my roommate, (not Mark, he's rarely generous) and the fact that the production is taking and they were papering the hell out of the house tonight I saw Cry-Baby, John Waters latest movie turned Broadway musical.

Over all... okay. Not great, but not terrible. I think my friend Kevin said it best, if this had been an off-Broadway show we would have thought it was great and loved the whole experience. As a Broadway show... it was lacking.

The show wanted to be an over the top parody of 50's morales and attitudes. The "Squares" being perfectly up front and content in their racism and xenophobia. The "Drapers" being perfectly contented in their wrong-side-of-the-tracks lives, pregnant teens, seedy riverbank rendezvous and all.

Somehow they it never went far enough over the top.

For attitude I would compare it to "The Great Trailer Park Musical." It has similar types and themes, but Trailer Park knew where that cusp was and gladly ran it over as they passed by. For parody and camp value I would compare it to "Evil Dead," but there again, Evil Dead plowed beyond any sense of propriety and reveled in its state as something beyond either a musical parody or a parody of the movie. Cry-Baby has the elements, a character in an iron lung, songs about French kissing, a supporting cast that includes a woman with an ass J-Lo would be jealous of, a lunatic, and Harriet Harris. But they kept pulling their punches.

The characters who knew how to play the show like Alli Mauzy who played the aforementioned lunatic Lenore, and Carly Jibson who played the pregnant Pepper (Rikki Lake's role in the movie) pushed their characters to heights (or perhaps depths) that demanded attention. Mauzy in particular was so commanding that even as a background player in dance scenes I was more interested in watching what she was doing than the leads. The rest, sadly including the leads, would get just to the edge of finding what they needed and fall back. I think the biggest example of this was the final number. In a scene that includes 5 characters in star spangled outfits, a man on stilts, a woman in a pie costume, and a woman dressed a giant pack of Lucky Strikes... I expected more. Elizabeth Stanley's patriotic dress (in the picture above) was actually tamer than several of the outfits that she had previously worn in the show, and that sums up the whole show, at the point where they could have been most outrageous, they chose a milder route.

Scenically Scott Pask, whose sets I seem to review a lot, (he designed both Lt. of Inishmoore, and Wedding Singer) did a fine job. The sets were completely passable, though there was nothing splashy or groundbreaking (hmm... same thing I said about Wedding Singer...). The attention to detail was lovely, and there were some really great moments, like the bridal shop, and the license plate factory. But not much that wowed me. Not that I think about it it was actually very similar to Wedding singer, a couple of the set pieces could have been reused (the heroines houses and the suburbia groundrows for instance) with little difficulty.

If anything I'd say go for the dancing. There are some great dance numbers, though someone needs to tell Charlie Sutton that he can take his hand off his crotch every once in a while. Pawing at your balls for the whole show is a poor substitution for characterization.

Lupone's Gypsy... Meh. (A Review)


Earlier this week I managed to catch one of the few remaining performances of Patti Lupone at the City Center's limited run production of Gypsy. This production has been getting rave reviews all over the city and featured a powerhouse cast of Patti Lupone, Laura Benanti, and Boyd Gaines. The director of the production was the author of the musical's book. There was a larger than standard orchestra. In short everything that a Broadway production would ever need to succeed, right? Somehow though it fell far short of what I was expecting.

First... let me just preface this by saying that maybe I am a harsh critic at the moment. I have spent the last three months immersed in another production of this show so I've imagined the staging and production of this show in many different ways. This production however came up short in almost every aspect that I can imagine.

First, Ms. Lupone. She's great. She has a great voice, an enormous stage presence and a thrilling electricity to her performances. It would seem like this was the role she was born to play, and in fact many have said exactly that. They were wrong. She chewed this role up and steamrolled over it in a way that left no room for sympathy for her. I know Mama Rose is supposed to be a hard as nails bitch of a woman, but jeez... give me some reason to believe that Herbie put up with her for all those years. The worst example of this was the final number, the famous "Rose's Turn." Lupone shredded this song, screaming, sobbing, belting and pounding every note with nowhere for the audience to breathe and nowhere for a character to come through.

Anyone who read my past reviews will know that I have no love for Laura Benanti either, especially her performance in Wedding Singer, but this was the perfect role for her. Her boyish looks and understated performance were great for Louise, and her transformation into Gypsy Rose Lee was amazing. I could really feel her emotion as she looked into the mirror and stated "I'm pretty Mama!" I don't know if it is the way she carried herself, or costuming or what but as Louise she seemed 6 inches shorter and much less endowed than she did as the tall and buxom Gypsy. THIS performance worked.

The direction was a whole different matter, and the place where I think the production really fell down. The performances were often staged much more in the manner of a reading, or a concert, sung out to the audience and in total disregard to the other players on stage. The sisters' song "If Mama Were Married" is supposed to be the moment where these two girls who had long been played against each other by their mother realize that if they work together they have much more power. The staging of this production though placed them on opposite sides of the stage with very little interaction between them, and not so much as a hug at the end of the number. Similarly the climatic resolution of the conflict between Rose and Gypsy at the end of "Rose's Turn" was undermined by a scenery move that was very unfortunately timed, and Gypsy walks away, alone at the end of the number leaving Rose alone on stage. That piece of staging lets you know, here at the end of the show, that it had really been all about Patti all along, and the other performances and players truly didn't matter as much as her moment in the sun.

The set design left quite a bit to be desired as well. I understand that it was minimal and constrained, but several of the choices for what did end up on stage were very odd. The first moment that it caught my eye was in the kitchen at the beginning. The scenery consisted of a door, a table and chairs and a large breakfront. The breakfront however featured several doors that were askew and off the hinges, and drawers with missing pulls. It was grossly overstated to the point of looking like something out of a Loonie Tunes design. The rest of the show didn't fare much better. The strippers' dressing room at the Burlesque house didn't seem dirty enough, and Gypsy's upscale star dressing room at the end didn't seem clean enough.

But the biggest WTF moment of the show was the sheep. This show traditionally features several live animals, a dog, a monkey, a bird, and a sheep. In this performance the dog was stuffed. The bird was cut. The monkey was referred to off stage but never seen. And the sheep... the sheep was a puppet. A rod puppet performed by an actor in dark grey period dress who didn't look at all different from the other dozen performers on stage at the moment. He runs through the scene, performing a running sheep rod puppet, and is chased by the other members of the cast. I've seen shows with puppets, and I've designed shows with puppets, and one of the cardinal rules is that the puppets have to be established. The audience has to know how to think of the puppet. Is the performer to be ignored? Or is the performer just as important as the puppet? Are the other cast members aware that the puppet character is in any way different, or do they accept that this is a real animal? In this case the sheep is the only puppet in the show, and is only performed once. With no previous puppets to help us establish what this thing is supposed to be the performance was jarring and bizarre. If you are going to do it for the sheep, why not the monkey? Why not the bird? Or a cat? It was a bad choice in a sea of bad choices.

Gypsy closed on Sunday so you won't get a chance to see it, but frankly... you aren't missing anything. If, as it seems most of the audience did, you only want to hear Lupone as Gypsy.. buy the inevitable album and consider yourself lucky.

What the...?!?


Edward Scissorhands
, as a dance piece, at one of the most respected "art theatre" houses in New York City, The Brooklyn Academy of Music. What is the world coming to? This production is entirely wordless, existing purely in a world of dance.

I don't even know what else to say about it. It looks... well... it looks... awful. But BRILLIANTLY awful. I mean... look closely at this next shot:


Those are people. In shrub costumes. SHRUB. COSTUMES.

The mind boggles.

(Aside to Kevin: THIS is my Ghost Rider.)

subUrbia: A REVIEW

Last Thursday Kevin passed along a couple tickets to the Second Stage production of Eric Bagosian's "subUrbia." This has been a favorite show of mine for a few years, primarily because it is high on my list of shows that I would want to design.

The show is just a bit dated at this point (It was originally produced in the mid 90's and is a bit tangled in the mire of that time period) so I was thrilled to find out that Bagosian himself had done some rewrites and edits to the script to bring it into a more current time frame. I really wanted this show to be good. Unfortunately I ended up being disappointed.

The cast was decent. It included two child-stars (Kieran Culkin and Gaby Hoffman) and several award winners and nominees, but the only real stand-out was Peter Scanavino as Tim, the disaffected former Naval Airman, and the de facto leader of the group of slackers that the show centers around. Whether he has a brilliant make-up artist, or just lives the lifestyle himself Scanavino certainly looks the part of a guy on a 3 day bender, and he carried the cast through the rest of the show. Whenever he was on stage he commanded the attention of the audience well above the rest. The others on stage worked to varying degrees of success, but none of them really managed to connect fully to their roles or the audience. Hoffman was especially lackluster and never seemed as if she belonged with the rest of the cast. Her character, Sooze, is the one bright spot in the show, the one character with the ambition and possibility to move beyond the situations of the town they live in. Through her we should be able to see in sharp relief the opportunities that everyone else is allowing to slip past. Instead she came off as spoiled, and snobbish, placing herself above it all without motivation.

The biggest problem I had with the show was the set. The design opportunity of this show, the thing that appeals to me, is that it is an absolutely real place, that has to portrayed in that way. The grounding reality of the show is in it's setting. The entire show takes place in the parking lot of a suburban convenience store and includes the interior of the store, as well as the roof, dumpsters, and some of the surrounding details. Scenic designer Richard Hoover did a solid job of creating the reality of the space, and I applaud what he managed, but it was also part of the ultimate downfall of the play. Hoover chose to present the entire front of the store relatively flat to the audience. His mistake came in presenting far too much of the interior. The depth of the store interior ate a LOT of stage space. 90% of the play takes place outside the store and while it was visually appealing to have the storefront represented so well it ultimately left too little room for the action and forced the actors into a small lane of space that really only allowed for movement parallel to the seating. The limited movement in the limited space (coupled with the limited acting) left the whole show feeling shallow. This was a textbook example of the design impeding the show. I'm not sure if a deeper design, with more acting space could have saved the whole thing, but it certainly couldn't have hurt it.

In all I'd say B-, which depresses me. There's potential here that they missed.

Evil Dead: The Musical A REVIEW

Okay... wow. Last night I had the opportunity to see a preview of Evil Dead: The Musical. I'll say that there are two entertainment trends that I am not fond of: movie musicals, and tongue in cheek remakes. Movie musicals are the Broadway equivalent of making a TV show into a movie. After "The Producers" every producer in New York started mining Blockbuster looking for something they could put onstage. Some have been good ("Holy Grail") some have been bad ("Dirty Rotten Scoundrels") and some have only been fair ("The Wedding Singer"), but it just seems to me that there have to be better sources. Speaking of TV shows going to the silver screen why do they all essentially make fun of the show they are emulating? Granted some are worthy of mockery like "The Dukes of Hazard" but I'd have much rather seen a solid romantic comedy based on "Bewitched" than what we got. Evil Dead falls squarely into both of these pet peeves, so how does it fare? Not well frankly.

It's fun, don't get me wrong. And it has moments of brilliance. There are some pure laughs to be had, and some fun numbers, but in the end it was all a little flat. My first complaint is that the show doesn't seem to be sure of what it is mocking exactly. At times it is certainly poking holes in the source material, and at other times it attacks horror movies as a genre, but it also takes some serious shots at musical theatre convention. The audience that came to see this show because of the first part of the title (Evil Dead) is not going to get the musical theatre jokes, and the audience that came for the second part (The Musical) might be alienated by the blood and geek based humor.

Scattered through all that though are some great touches. The zombie masks are fantastic and the transformations are often seamless. The first transformation in fact was so full of theatre magic that I am still not 100% sure how they pulled it off. The rest of the special effects fall into one of two categories: either they are magical and fascinating, or they are played for laughs. One headless zombie is obviously a walking joke, while at the same time there are moments like a scalping that are enthralling. The jokes also seem to go to either extreme, overplayed, or understated. The understated humor frankly works the best. Ryan Ward as Ash plays this show as if he is the only sane person onstage. He only breaks the fourth wall and convention when his character runs up against some aspect of the plot that is obviously far fetched or against logic. On the other hand Darryl Winslow as Jake beats every line he is given with a stick trying to get every ounce of comedy he can out of it. In the end his performance suffers. Winslow doesn't trust the script to carry him the way that Ward does.

The show doesn't disappoint in some aspects it hits all the high points of the movie ("Good. Bad. I'm the guy with the gun.") and it certainly delivers on it's promise of blood and gore. Officially the first three rows are the "splatter zone" where the seats are covered in plastic, and you probably should be too, but unofficially members of my party were hit by spraying blood as far back as the 7th row.

I'd say that if you are a rabid fan of the movie, or you can enjoy an evening of fairly mindless entertainment with some blood thrown in then you should go. If you are in any way looking for off-kilter greatness then you're going to be a bit disappointed.

The Lieutenant of Inishmore: A Review

Tonight I was fortunate enough to see the Broadway production of Martin McDonagh's "The Lieutenant of Inishmore." First let me say that McDonagh is rapidly becoming my favorite playwright. I saw the Broadway production of "The Pillowman" last year and was amazed and astounded by it. Inishmore does not fail to live up to my expectations. It is not a perfect play, it is obvious having seen Pillowman first that Inishmore is an earlier work, and that McDonagh has matured quite a bit in his writing. Pillowman explored themes pertaining to the power of fiction, and the written word, and did it in ways that left viewers speechless from awe. Inishmore left me speechless as well, but more at the audacity of it than at the depth of character or symbol. The easiest way that I can come up with to describe it is this: Imagine an episode of "Three's Company" as directed by Quentin Tarantino.

I'm going to give you few seconds to imagine that.

You still aren't imagining anything as bold or jaw-droppingly shocking as this show.

The basic premise of the show revolves around a dead cat. This cat though, is a special cat. He is owned, and deeply beloved by an Irish terrorist. An Irish terrorist so batshit crazy in fact that the IRA won't have him and he has had to form his own "splinter group" in order to act out his desire to free Ireland. So, now, go back to your imagination and try to picture what Crissy and Janet might have done to hide that cat if Jack were a homicidal maniac on par with Hannibal Lector.

Act 1 is primarily concerned with putting all of the pieces on the board. The cat. The boy who found the cat's body. The terrorist and his father. The rest of the IRA splinter cell. The young, hometown girl who idolizes and lusts after the terrorist. You also get all the puzzle pieces pertaining to who really killed the cat, who will be taking the blame for that act, who knows the whole story, and what has been done to cover up the deed. With all the dominos in place Act 2 is simply about watching how they fall. This is why I chose a sitcom to compare this show to. The occurrences are pretty predictable, but even as you figure out where the show is going, you won't believe your eyes as it unfolds onstage. Each level of outrageousness opens the door to something else and you will catch yourself repeating the phrase "Oh no... they can't..." under your breath several times. But yes... they can. And yes... they do.

Like most sitcoms the show is pretty surface. For a show with a terrorist as the main character there is surprisingly little political talk and nothing by way "message" that the show is there to deliver. The show simply is what it is, the blackest black comedy you can imagine.

On a personal level I found the set very interesting. Several years ago I worked at the Williamstown Theatre Festival as a props artisan. One of the shows that I worked on that summer was "Philadelphia, Here I Come" by Brian Friehl. I loved that set. It was very simple, a stereotypical box set, the cross section of a house showing a dining room and a bedroom in a traditional Irish home. The landscape of the stage around the house was a near perfect replica of a field of black slate. That set was designed by Hugh Landwehr. When I entered the Lyceum Theatre tonight I was presented with a box set, a cross section of a traditional Irish home set in a landscape of a black field of slate. With a few subtle changes in the details of the house it could have been the same set. On referring to the Playbill I fully expected to find Hugh Landwehr's name. To my surprise though I found Scott Pask, another highly successful NY designer. The interesting thing though... that summer, as Hugh was installing his set upstairs on the mainstage of Williamstown... Scott Pask was downstairs in the Nykos stage installing his own set for another show. Do you think he might have seen the set upstairs?

What really burns me is that I didn't get to steal it first! It's a great design element.

The Wedding Singer: A Review


When I first heard that The Wedding Singer was being adapted to a Broadway musical my feelings were mixed. I'm not a big fan of the cross-pollination of Broadway and Hollywood, especially the movie-to-musical phenomenon that The Producers begat. On the other hand I do love Adam Sandler movies, and I loved this one in particular.

The show is great. It helps tremendously that Tim Herlihy, who wrote the original screenplay for the movie, was involved in the adaptation of the show to stage. All of the jokes that worked so well in the movie are still in the show, though in some cases shifted to other characters or other situations. I was afraid that the lack of the great 80's songs would detract from the show, but the original songs that were written for the show had a great 80's feel, lot's of synthesizer and electronic drumlines, and evoked enough of the 80's that I didn't miss the others. The three original songs from the movies did make the transition to stage. All of the signature Sandler movie characters also made it to stage-- the homeless guy, the quietly gay character, the freakish ugly woman-- so the feel of the movie was firmly in place. The re-write to deal with the inability of the show to have Billy Idol as a star was nothing short of brilliant.

The director John Rando who won the Tony for Urinetown, was also a huge boon for this production. Several off kilter directorial decisions were necessary to make this production work on stage and Rando was certainly up to that task. The show was full of quirky, surreal moments that added to the hilarity of the show, as well as heightening the theatricality of the production.

The scenic design of the show, while not groundbreaking, was well done, with lots of great touches of detail. I especially enjoyed the New Jersey suburbia-scape background, the pastel pink and turquoise uber-80's design of the ballroom, and the solution for the scene outside Julia's bedroom window. The synergy between the design team, the writing team, and the direction created a formidable production, with lots of great moments.

There is a problem with this show however. Actually two. The leads. Neither of the leads, Stephen Lynch as Robbie or Laura Benanti as Julia had anywhere near the charm and sweetness of Sandler and Barrymore. Benanti was particularly bland, with very little to recommend her as a soulmate. Her voice is great, and she does great things with the songs that she is given, but her book moments are barely distinguishable from the ensemble. She does nothing to elevate Julia to the star level of the show, and is outplayed in every scene she appears in. Lynch has another problem to deal with, and that is the shadow of Adam Sandler. Tim Herlihy has written nearly every movie that Sandler has ever appeared in and he knows how to write for Sandler's acting style, and the quirks of his delivery. Lynch struggled on stage to find a way to deliver lines that were tailor made for Adam Sandler in his own voice. Sometimes he aped Sandler (the drunken wedding banquet performance after Linda leaves him) and at other times he attempted a more personal delivery (his interaction with his grandmother) that unfortunately fell flat. Sandler always comes off as if he is the only sane person surrounded by a world full of freaks and weirdos. Lynch fell to far into the latter, and was never able to climb back out.

The shining stars of this production are the supporting cast and ensemble. Every single scene is stolen by them, even when Robbie and Julia are the only people on stage. Felicia Finley as Robbie's fiance Linda especially stands out. Finley's Linda approaches every single moment of her life as if she were in a heavy metal music video. She performs splits, hair tosses, and thong revealing high kicks in ways that make them seem as if they are no more out of the ordinary that stepping when you walk. Linda is aided in this by several well placed interactions with scenery. Seemingly innocuous pieces of set dressing provide her with her own private wind machines, steam jets, and stripper poles. Her appearances on stage are the highlights of the show.

So... over all... great show, well written and produced... but unfortunately poorly cast. Fans of the 80's will be happy with it, and will enjoy the production. Fans of the movie will struggle to divorce Sandler and Barrymore from their familiar roles. Fans of musical theatre will like it if they fall more into the category of Full Monty fan than the category of Oklahoma fan.

Now THAT'S A Show!!

Wrapping up my week of theatre Roommates K & M and I saw "The Great American Trailer Park Musical" tonight. So much more satisfying than my previous theatre going experience.

Here is a show that shouldn't work at all. Set in a trailer park in Florida it liberally mixes rock, country, and Broadway musical styles, for songs about huffing cooking spray, the joys of watching Sally Jesse Raphael, and what to do when a stripper is sleeping with your husband. Polyester and fake wood paneling are both featured heavily in the design. Somehow though, it all gels. The show is funny, touching, and a pleasure to watch.

The set design features such authentic touches as a tire cover with a naked girl riding a horse airbrushed onto it, an oversized satellite dish on a camper, and a rusty water tower overlooking everything. The designer was clever and innovative in finding ways to shift to other locations, and moving inside and outside the various trailers. Good old fashioned scenic design, that worked.

The plot and execution of the songs was spot on perfect in the show as well. How can you resist a show with lyrics about spray cheese, road kill, and pole dancing? The phrase "Like a nail, I will press on" will forever be a part of my language now.

THIS one, I'll recommend to anyone who'll listen.

The Woman In What Now?

Tonight I had the inestimable honor of seeing Andrew Lloyd Weber's newest theatrical endeavor "The Woman In White."

If I believed in God I would have prayed to have this abomination struck from the face of the Earth with a fury not seen since Sodom and Gomorra were obliterated.

This show, in the simplest terms is BAD. The songs are boring. The acting is overblown and melodramatic. The set is ill-conceived. The plot is barely discernible. The characterization, where it exists at all, is inconsistent and the character choices are illogical. The single best thing in the show is (I shit you not) a white rat who performs tricks during one of the songs. The rat doesn't come on until Act 2, so if you get tricked into seeing the show don't leave during intermission, even though you'll be tempted to, because you'll miss the rat. I promise you, you'll want to see the rat after sitting through Act 1.

This appears to have been adapted from the Victorian era novel by Wilkie Collins, but from reading articles on the book it seems that all the good stuff went out the window. Gone are the comedic characters of the nurse and the maid, gone the detail that one of the sisters about who this story centers, the smart one naturally, is supposed to be gargoyle ugly, and the other pretty, but dumb as a bag of hammers. Also gone seems to be most of the plot. What we are left with is, unfortunately an idiot plot that could have been cleared up early in Act 1 if either of the girls had thought to press their uncle for information on the title character.

The set. I applaud innovation in scenic design, and theatrical presentation. Really, I do. The scenographer responsible for this set conceived a set of semi-circular moving walls that could reconfigure and revolve around the stage. 99% of the scenery is computer generated and projected onto these walls. This allows for movement within the scenery, almost instantaneous shifts between location, and would seem to give the opportunity for dramatically different looks for each location since the only limits would be the imagination of the artist doing the computer renderings. In reality the whole thing looks like something artistically on par with the first generation of Doom type games (and I was really wishing I had my shotgun). It looks doubly bad when very realistic furniture and costumes are put in front of it. There were also inexplicable oddities in the renderings. Why for instance would a designer choose to render some of the objects grossly out of scale with the people on stage? Occasionally the audience was confronted with fireplaces that were 12 feet tall, and books on shelves that were 3 feet tall. One scene played out in front of the exterior of a pawn shop for no reason that I can figure out. Being outside made the dialogue seem forced and unrealistic, and in the end the scene didn't make sense. They had to render both the exterior and interior of the shop. It would have cost them nothing to play the scene "inside" why not do it?

The most annoying thing about the show was the blocking. (The movement of the actors for those not familiar with the jargon.) The center of the stage was a revolve, (a circular floor that "revolves," get it?) and the walls were roughly circular, making the whole show seem like it was happening inside a hat box. All this circular stuff meant that the actors spent an awful lot of time running... in circles. I could not begin to count the number of times that the actors, singularly or in groups, literally jogged in circles around the stage. Or walked. Or danced. Or (again, I shit you not) skipped. In circles. I get it, we were supposed to be, metaphorically, watching the show through a zoetrope, the Victorian equivalent of animation, but it would have been SO much more satisfying and affective if the director could have figured out a way to break the pattern and work both within and against the shape of the set.

I won't speak directly to the songs, or the singing, or the acting because I don't really have the authority to do so, being neither a director or a singer. Other of course than saying that I didn't enjoy them. I will say this: you know that you are in trouble when at the pivotal moment of the performance, when the audience should be most enraptured and absorbed... they giggle.

This show cost $8.5 million. I'd have given them a better design for half that.

My Theatrical Week

Three times this week Roommate K and I have had a conversation along the lines of: "What have you been hearing about show A?"

"Good/Bad/Indifferent, but I really want to see it."

"Yeah, me too."

All three times, within 48 hours of that conversation, one or the other of us has been offered free tickets to the show that we were discussing. (My amazing powers of coincidence at work again.) So within a week I will be seeing three Broadway shows: Chitty Chitty Bang Bang, Woman in White, and The Great American Trailer Park Musical. None of these shows have gotten great reviews, in the case of Woman in White Roommate K and I spent about 20 minutes brutally dissecting a sampler CD that he received in the mail, mainly trying to figure out what the hell the plot might be.

We've already seen Chitty. The effects were AMAZING, even beyond the flying car the show was full of effect driven moments that were alternatively funny and breathtaking. The show itself... kind of a yawner. The songs were good, but weren't "big" enough for the stage. The story and especially the songs seemed subsumed by the visuals. It was a fun show though, and I was happy to have seen it, if for no other reason than I got to see what Disney money can do onstage.

Tomorrow is Woman in White, the show I'm anticipating the least. The songs I've heard sound like something that would have gotten cut from Phantom, and as I said, I cannot discern what the plot is supposed to be either from the commercials or from the mailer that they sent with the CD. But again, I'm happy to be going. Maybe I'll luck out and it will be one of those shows that are so bad that they loop back around to being good again.